• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Bourbon Mill

At Bourbon Mill, nestled in New Oxford, PA, we celebrate the heart of American cuisine within a warm and inviting atmosphere. Our story begins with a commitment to quality, serving cherished classics and innovative dishes that bring people together. From perfectly seasoned BBQ ribs to unique options like gator bites and crafted cocktails, every menu item reflects our dedication to flavor and memorable dining experiences. With features like outdoor seating, takeout, and delivery, we strive to cater to every guest's needs. Join us for a delightful taste of comfort food, where great taste and community meld seamlessly.

Bourbon Mill: Reviews & Ratings

Mary B.
Mary B.

Stopped here on our way to Gettysburg when everyone was hungry. Had no idea what to expect but everything we ordered was so good. It was so unexpected and we were thrilled. It was early lunchtime and we were the only ones in there when we first got there and it did take awhile to be served but I figured maybe the server wasn't quite ready yet.

Andrew S.
Andrew S.

I was here on a Thursday night. It was not crowded. Service was quick to take my order. They have gator bites. This for me is a major plus. They always hit the spot. They were hot with great flavor. Their French onion soup. Is some of the best in the area. However portion size lacks for the price. 10.00 for a bowl. It is about a 1.00 a bite. I hope this is not the norm. I can say I recommend this place more than before. It has good flavor. Value this visit was mixed.

Thomas W.
Thomas W.

First time here. I was in for lunch on a Saturday. Service was top notch, and bartenders made excellent cocktail and food suggestions. Wings were very tasty. Cocktails were great and they have a very extensive beer list. Restaurant is clean and spacious.

William W.
William W.

Was driving by and decided to try this place as the outside looked very unique. The prices of their food was great and got plenty of food. Also has a great selection of craft beer. Worth trying if you're in the area.

Annetta
Annetta

Food is delish, service always with a smile and ambiance, low lighting and could be very romantic. Thanks Nick.

Jeff S.
Jeff S.

Great , service , food, and prices. Good live music outside and inside depending on time of year.

Carol O.
Carol O.

BEST EVER wings. Service was phenomenal & patrons were friendly. My daughter & is got there around 3pm for a late lunch/early dinner. Even though we sat at a table bartender greeted us waited on us right away. We had wings appetizer & shared crab tacos. Wings (bourbon BBQ) were as meaty as chicken legs. Totally YUMMY!

Scott C.
Scott C.

Tried to go to another restaurant in Gettysburg for a party of 12, called ahead on Wednesday and tried again on Sunday and they would not let us to out our name on the 45-60 minute wait list even after I explained the reason being my mother has some medical issues and couldn't drive 20inutes and then wait up to an hour for a table, even offering my credit card to add our name. So we pivoted and called the Bourbon Mill to see if they could accommodate. They said head in over and we will take care of you. We got there about 20 minutes later and they already had a table set for our group out in the patio area and seated us right away. The servers were on point, took our drink and appetizer order, make sure to get the wings and the crab pretzel, both amazing. Drinks were never empty, the food was fantastic and several servers and managers constantly checked on us. It was outstanding service and food. Please support these guys as they take customer service and quality food seriously. Will definitely be back.

Location

  • Bourbon Mill
    4797 York Rd, New Oxford, PA 17350 Hotline: (717) 624-8987

Welcome to Bourbon Mill, a delightful gem nestled at 4797 York Rd, New Oxford, PA. This establishment shines brightly in the American dining scene, specializing in bars and comfort food that is sure to satiate your cravings.

Bourbon Mill stands out not just for its appetizing menu but also for its welcoming atmosphere. It's a place where you can relax with outdoor seating, enjoy a night with friends during happy hour specials, or even grab a quick bite with takeout and delivery options. Additionally, the restaurant is wheelchair accessible and offers on-site parking, making it easy for everyone to enjoy a great meal.

The menu is richly varied, presenting an enticing array of soups, salads, sandwiches, and more. For a comforting touch, you can indulge in the housemade Broccoli Cheddar Soup, a creamy blend that warms the belly. Alternatively, the Chili Crock Cream of Crab Soup offers a hearty, seafood delight, while the French Onion Brisket Soup introduces a savory twist to a classic favorite.

  • Freshness First: The salads, such as the refreshing Caesar and the robust Chef Trio, showcase a commitment to fresh ingredients, making them a perfect start to your meal.
  • Sandwich Sensations: The sandwiches here are nothing short of divine. The Big Easy Sandwich, laden with pepper jack cheese and crispy fried onion strings, provides a satisfying crunch, while the Bourbon Melt is a comforting mashup of flavors that no burger lover should miss.
  • Drinks and Vibes: You can also enjoy an extensive cocktail and craft beer selection. The bartenders are friendly, ensuring your drink is as delightful as your food.

Certainly, Bourbon Mill has garnered a reputation for quality food and welcoming service. Guests like Mary B. and William W. have praised the unexpected flavors and great prices, while Thomas W. noted the top-notch service and the extensive beer list. Even though some reviews mention portions and speed of service could be improved, the overall sentiments reflect a positive dining experience.

With free Wi-Fi and various amenities like smoking allowed areas and a drive-thru for on-the-go customers, Bourbon Mill invites you to come as you are. Whether you're seeking a cozy dinner or a quick lunch break, this establishment promises a delightful culinary experience that keeps guests coming back for more.

Don't miss out on experiencing the comforting flavors of Bourbon Mill. Call (717) 624-8987 to make a reservation or swing by for a taste of what you've been missing!